Home

Current Issues

History of Karachi

Karachi Master Plans

Economy

Land Use

Housing

Evictions

Basic Urban Services

Transport and Traffic 

Management

Law & Order Situation

Education

Health

Environment

Karachi Census

Karachi City Maps

About URC Karachi

Some Important Links

URC Website Index

Contact Us

 



       

MARCH 2010

 

 

 

 

ISSUES:

 

 

 

 

The Enterprising Poor

 

THE dynamics of a designated ‘poor’ household are interesting enough to initiate a debate on its own. There are no two opinions about the incidence of poverty and in its steady rise. Having said that, there is also no denying the fact that the poor are in no mood to throw in the towel. They are putting up a brave face against heavy odds. 


The number of people living below the poverty line, according to the Economic Survey 2008-09, has gone up from 33.8 in FY08 to 36.1 per cent in FY09. While saying that “the latest poverty figures are not available”, the Annual Report 2008-09 of the State Bank of Pakistan also highlighted the fact that the share of “severely food-insecure population” is expected to have increased by five percentage points to 28 in the year 2008. 


With rising poverty and an even worse social and economic disparity staring them in the face, the poor are taking charge of their own lives instead of depending on the state to come to their rescue. While those condemned to an existence in a rural setting have a plethora of additional elements to fight against – inadequate infrastructure, lack of opportunities and resources as well as a feudal mindset – the urban poor have relatively easier accessibility to resources and opportunities. And, by the looks of it, they are making the most of these opportunities. 


The global reference range for poverty set by the World Bank is $1.25-$2 per day, or Rs105-Rs170 per day. In developing countries, around 3.5 billion people live within the range. 


The minimum wage set by the government, Rs6,000 per month, is higher than the World Bank range, but these are apparently insufficient because just paying the rent even in shanty settlements takes a considerable chunk off the total. Education definitely is a luxury for the poor and children start earning or at least learning some trade by the time they are 10 years of age. The number of heads per household is pretty high and they wish to keep it that way because everyone is an earning hand and it is a clear case of being ‘more, the merrier’. 


In his mid-40s, Mujahid Hussain lives in a two-room rented space in Malir area along with his wife and seven children; four sons and three daughters. He works as a helper to a carpenter who pays him Rs4,000 per month. He makes on an average another Rs2,000 to Rs3,000 by taking up minor woodwork assignments on his own at home. 


His wife and two elder daughters aged 17 and 15 together earn about Rs3,000 against stitching jobs which they take directly from within the neighbourhood as well from some tailoring shops. Next come his three sons – 14, 13 and 12 years of age – and they add an impressive Rs7,000 to the family income. 


The first two work with auto-mechanics and have completed their free internships which means they make at least Rs100 per day, while the younger one helps out a roadside vendor selling sugarcane juice against which he gets Rs25-30 per day. 


The only non-earning members in the household are Mujahid’s daughter aged 8 and son who is two years her junior. They may not be earning, but they are not inactive. The daughter carries out much more household chores than one would normally imagine of a girl her age. This gives more time for her mother and sisters to spend on their stitching assignments. The son is the regular messenger-cum-delivery boy of the family, keeping liaison with tailoring shops and clients in the neighbourhood. 


The youngest two are still in school – grade III and II, respectively – while for the elders it came to a halt as soon as they completed grade V, which, according to Mujahid, is “good enough for all practical purposes”. 


With his basic income of Rs4,000, Mujahid will be left with just half that much after paying just the rent. Even with his own additional income he will struggle to feed the nine mouths in the house, but the overall family income of over Rs15,000 – sometimes going as high as Rs20,000 – he can not only survive, but survive well. They have a television set with cable connection which is the lone, but effective source of entertainment. The family is also saving whatever it can for the wedding of the two elder daughters which is something still at least a couple of years away by which time the three sons would have grown up in age, exposure and earning potential, while the younger two would have joined the domestic workforce. 


The family has its routine share of grudges against the system, but has absolutely no doubt that the solution to the problem lies in their own hands. It has neither the time nor the inclination to run after various poverty-alleviation schemes that are announced by successive governments from time to time. 


The Mujahid household is not an isolated story. From Surjani Town and New Karachi to Saudabad and Khokhrapar, from Orangi to Korangi and even in localities that ring one posh area or the other in the heart of Karachi, the basic contours of the story remain pretty much the same. In fact it is true on the national scale as well otherwise things would have been much worse with 42.8 per cent of the population living below or around the poverty line. It is the only the enterprising nature of the common man which is helping him beat poverty without any assistance from the state.

(By Humair Ishtiaq, Dawn-13, 29/03/2010)

 

 

 

 

Clean drinking water still a distant dream


When nations around the world would be celebrating the World Water Day 2010 under the theme ‘Clean Water for a Healthy World’, the residents of the country’s biggest city and industrial hub, Karachi would be consuming highly polluted potable water.


The United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) announced to observe World Water Day every year on March 22 to highlight the importance of clean water in 1992 in a conference at Rio de Janeiro.


While, most countries have organised different events to highlight the importance of the day, one such event titled “The Longest Toilet Queue” has also been organised where thousands would participate worldwide from March 20 to 22, as an attempt for setting a Guinness World Record regarding global sanitation awareness. The majority of the citizens living in the slum settlements of the city would practically be standing in queues on the streets as they have no proper sanitation facilities. 


Despite tall claims by the government at various levels, the government authorities would celebrate the day with traditional criminal silence towards all water related issues. When it comes to clean potable water, Karachi is an example of sheer negligence, where the only source of drinking water to the city; the Keenjhar Lake is being polluted with sewerage and industrial waste. The lake a Ramsar site, rich wetland, protected game sanctuary and the biggest source of potable water to millions of residents of Karachi and Thatta districts, is being polluted with toxic effluent from industries, littering by tourists and washing of vehicles.


The lake is being polluted from toxic effluent from the industries of Kotri and Nooriabad and despite repeated requests by nature conservationists and environmentalists’, the government so far has done nothing to protect this lake.


Moreover, being the signatory of the 1971 convention held in the Iranian city of Ramsar, the Pakistan government is bound to protect Keenjhar Lake from pollution, but neither the government is bothering, nor the officials of the Ramsar convention have so far taken notice of this fast dying wetland.

(By Amar Guriro, DailyTimes-B1, 22/03/2010)

 

 

 

 

Education in Pakistan

 

Literacy rate 

Our education system has to meet the basic learning needs of our society emphasizing basic literacy and life skills, increasing access and completion of quality education, address gender problem, geographical and structural disparities, and enhance the efficiency of education governance.

 

According to Pakistan Social and Living Measurement (PSLM) Survey (2007-08), the overall literacy rate (age 10 years and above) is 56% (69% for male and 44% for female) in 2007- 08 compared to 55% (67% for male and 42% for female) in 2006-07. Literacy remains higher in urban areas (71%) than in rural areas (49%) and more in men (69%) compared to women (44%). When analyzed provincially, literacy rate in Punjab stood at 59 % followed by Sindh (56%), NWFP (49%) and Balochistan at 46%. The literacy rate of Punjab and Balochistan has improved considerably during 2006-07 to 2007-08

 

According to the PSLM Survey 2007-08, the overall school attendance (age 10 years and above) is 58% (71% for male and 46% for female) in 2007-08 compared to 56% (68 % for male and 44% for female) in 2005-06.

 

Province-wise school attendance (age 10 and above) for 2007-08 as against 2005-06 shows Punjab to be on the top (62% Vs 59%) followed by Sindh (58% Vs 56%), Balochistan (42 % Vs 34 %) and NWFP (51% Vs 51 %) to be at the lowest level. School attendance (age 10 years and above) remains higher in urban areas (73%) than in rural areas (51%) and more in men (71%) compared to women (46%). Nationally, the Gross Enrolment Rate (GER), sometimes referred to participation rate, which is the number of children attending primary school (age 5-9 years) divided by the number of children who ought to be attending. The GER in case oremained 91% between 2006-07 and 2007-08. Balochistan has shown noticeable increase in the respective period.

 

The Net Enrollment Rate (NER) refers to the number of students enrolled in primary school of primary school age divided by the number of children in the age group for that level of education. The NER as a whole in 2007-08 is 55% as compared to 56% in 2006-07. All the provinces have shown a decreasing trend, interestingly, rural areas exhibited higher rates in comparison to urban areas.

 

The Gender Parity Index (GPI) is the ratio of females’ enrolment to the males’ enrolment. A GPI of more than one indicates that, in proportion, to every male in the school, there is more than one female. The GPI for Pakistan as a whole in 2007- 08, is 0.64 compared to 0.63 in 2006-07.

 

Provincewise GPI is high in Punjab (0.69) followed by Sindh (0.61), NWFP (0.49) and Balochistan (0.35).

 

LEVEL OF EDUCATION

 

i) Pre-Primary Education

Pre-Primary Education constitutes Early Childhood Education (ECE), Prep or Kachi classes of children having age of 3-4 years. A decrease of 0.25% in Pre-Primary enrolment (7.403 million) in 2007-08 over 2006-07 (7.423 million) has been observed and during 2008-09, it is estimated to increase by 1.2%.

 

ii) Primary Education (Classes I – V)

A number of 157,899 Primary Schools with 438,823 Teachers are functional. Moreover, 124 new schools have been added since July 2007. GPI in Primary Education stood at 0.85.

 

iii) Middle Education (Classes VI-VIII)

40,837 Middle Schools with 320,609 Teachers are functional (Table 10.4) and 489 new schools have been added since July 2007.GPI remained 0.77 in Middle Education.

 

iv) Secondary Education (Classes IX-X)

23,967 Secondary Schools with 374,249 Teachers are functional 353 new schools have been added since July 2007 and GPI has been 0.75 in Secondary Education.

 

v) Higher Secondary / Inter Colleges

(Classes XI-XII)

An enrolment of 1.0 million is estimated in 2008-09 over 961,661 in 2007-08 and 902,448 in 2006-07. 3,218 Higher Secondary Schools /Inter Colleges with 74,222 Teachers are functional (Table 10.4). 74 new schools / Inter Colleges have been added since July 2007. GPI has been 0.99 in Higher Secondary Education.

 

vi) Degree Colleges Education (Classes XIIIXIV)

An enrolment of 361,072 is expected in 2008-9 in Degree Colleges over 352,302 in 2007-8 and 348,814 in 2006-07. 1,198 Degree Colleges with 20,976 Teachers are functional. 21 new Degree Colleges have been added since July 2007 and GPI has been 1.55 in Degree Colleges.

 

vii) Universities Education (Classes XV onwards)

An enrolment of 741,092 is estimated in 2008-09 in Higher Education over 640,061 in 2006-07. Four new Universities have been added since July 2007, making the total number to 124 universities with 46,893 Teachers in both Private and Public Sectors. GPI has been 0.86 in University Education. Over the past three years, 17 new universities had been granted Charters. Majority of these have been opened in areas where Higher Education opportunities were previously unavailable. Twenty-three new and advance disciplines were launched.Furthermore, 11 foreign institutions were allowed to operate in Pakistan through franchising / collaborative arrangements with local institutions of higher education.

(Source Economic survey of Pakistan 2008 09)

 

 

 

 

Child killed, several injured, 300 huts destroyed in shanty town blaze


Around 250 to 300 huts in Shanti Nagar were destroyed in a blaze which engulfed the area late Friday night. A child died and several people were injured in the fire, which was reported in a shanty town near Majeed Para, Shanti Nagar, in the Aziz Bhatti police limits.


A similar fire, two years ago in the area, had claimed the lives of three children. The residents, however, had rebuilt the shanties, and gone back to living in the area that has been occupied by them for the past 20 to 25 years.


The police said that the fire erupted suddenly late Friday night and quickly engulfed all the huts. The residents tried to help themselves and save the women and children. In the meantime, the police and fire tenders reached the place and began rescue operations. Some of the injured people were identified as five-year-old Danish, his mother Fauzia, Abdul Rasheed, Aasma, three-year-old Natasha, 40-year-old Ghulam Nabi, 45-year-old Fida Hussain, and Akmal. Danish died on the way to the hospital due to severe burn wounds.


It took a total of three hours and 12 fire tenders from the City District Government Karachi and other departments to bring the blaze under control. The residents of the area later launched a protest and alleged that the fire was the result of a conspiracy of land-grabbers, who had been after the plot for several years.


Abdul Kareem, a resident of the area who was also injured in the blaze, said that he was a labourer by profession. He had been collecting dowry for a month for his daughter’s wedding which was scheduled for next Sunday. The fire, however, destroyed everything.


Another victim, Abdul Sattar, who is also a labourer by profession, said that at the time of fire, he was helping others save items from their huts, when all of a sudden, his house caught fire too. He lost Rs60,000 cash.


Sattar said that he belonged to Multan, and had a plot of land there. A few weeks ago, his brothers had sold the plot, and sent him his share of the money, which came to about Rs50,000. In addition, Rs10,000 were his life’s saving. All of this was lost in the fire.


The area comprised around 250 to 300 huts, all of which were destroyed in the fire, rendering the residents homeless. The police, however, have not been able to ascertain the cause of the blaze; further investigation is under way.


Agencies add: Sindh Chief Minister (CM) Syed Qaim Ali Shah has taken serious notice of the incident of fire in huts of a slum area in Gulshan-e-Iqbal in which an innocent girl died and several others were injured.


Qaim expressed his grief with the bereaved family and directed the Health Department to provide all-out facilities to the injured. 


Meanwhile, the MQM Rabita Committee also expressed concern over the incident. It called for initiating probe into the incident, according to a statement issued here by the MQM.


Sympathising with the victims of the incident, the Rabita Committee has called for providing financial assistance to all the victims.

(The News-13, 21/03/2010)

 

 

 

KCR revival delayed due to MDA-PR land dispute

 

The government’s efforts to revive Karachi Circular Railway (KCR) are reportedly being hampered by land issue between the Malir Development Authority (MDA) and the Pakistan Railways (PR). Donors are insisting on rehabilitating affected people prior to issuing loans, The News has learnt.


The main issue is that the PR’s land has been encroached upon, and JICA, the prospective donor, is insisting on arrangements for the settlement of the affected people before it provides financial assistance for the KCR, Land Utilisation Additional Secretary-III Dr Azhar Hussain said.


The dispute between the MDA and the PR over land in Bin Qasim Town had continued since 1982, and the chief minister’s advisor on planning and development, Dr Kaiser Bengali, had recently called a meeting to resolve the land issue. The MDA was of the view that it would withdraw its petition from the Sindh High Court if it were provided with alternative land and money for infrastructure development, Dr Hussain said.


Meanwhile, sources said that following the meeting about the KCR chaired by Dr Bengali on February 6, another meeting, chaired by Dr Hussain, was held on March 12 to expedite efforts to resolve the land issue. It was decided that the MDA and the PR authorities will ‘urgently’ withdraw their cases in view of the decisions taken in the February 6 meeting. According to official sources and documents available with The News, the MDA has agreed to submit to a competent authority, a proposal pertaining to its land withdrawal, alternative land and incurred expenditure. It was also decided that the City District Government Karachi and the Board of Revenue will continue to search for a ‘suitable’ alternative piece of land in lieu of the settlement of the land under question (350 acres in Deh Khanto,Bin Qasim Town). This land was selected for the rehabilitation of the people affected by the KCR project.


Officials said that the land dispute between the MDA and the PR was discussed at length during the meeting. The MDA representative informed the participants of the meeting about the withdrawal of the case pending before the SHC. He also raised the question of alternative land in lieu of withdrawal from 350 acres in Deh Khanto, and expenditure incurred so far on the land.


The Bin Qasim Town additional district officer (revenue) and Mukhtiarkar (revenue) informed the meeting that a piece of land as an alternative was identified in Deh Kotierero. This land, which belongs to the Sindh government was, however, declared ‘unsuitable’ by the MDA.


The land utilisation department will play an ‘active role’ after the withdrawal of the case and the approval of the Sindh chief minister for processing the case, an official privy to the decisions taken during the February 6 meeting told The News.

(By Imtiaz Ali, The News-13, 29/03/2010)

 

 

 

Sepa issued notices to over 1,000 industrial units for causing pollution

 

Following a massive industrial waste disposal operation in SITE industrial area last month, the Sindh Environmental Protection Agency (Sepa) has so far served notices to over 1,000 industrial units in Karachi for dumping solid waste in open places and discharging industrial effluent without chemical treatment into nullahs.


Of these 1,000 notices, 800 notices were solely served during the last couple of weeks to industries in SITE area from where the Sepa had arranged removal of roughly 11,500 tons of industrial waste following Supreme Court’s orders in this regard.


“Following the removal of around 11,500 tons of industrial waste from SITE area on Supreme Court’s directives, some 800 industrial units have so far been issued notices for violating environmental laws and dumping waste as per their previous practice,” a Sepa official told The News on Monday. The official, who requested not to be named as he was not authorized to speak to the media on the directives of DG Sepa Naeem Mughal, said that Sepa had constituted eight teams which were continuously inspecting the SITE industrial area as well as four other industrial estates in Karachi to check environmental violations by the industries.


“These 800 industries had been dumping their waste at the same places from where we (Sepa), with the help of SITE Association of Industries and SITE Limited, launched a massive waste disposal operation and removed thousands of tons of industrial waste in about 10 days,” he maintained.

 

In addition to industries violating waste disposal and effluent treatment laws, the administrations of SITE, Landhi and Korangi industrial estates had also been served notices in this regard, the official maintained. As many as 200 notices have been served to Landhi and Korangi industrial units for dumping waste and discharging waste water in nullahs without treatment, the Sepa official claimed, adding that administrative authorities of these areas had also been held responsible for such violations.


The Sepa official claimed that five different teams comprising Sepa experts and analysts were busy only in SITE industrial area, where they were pointing out industries violating environmental laws and were collecting samples from individual industrial units to check the extent of environmental pollution caused by them.


“The process of identifying industrial units and collecting data of pollution caused by them is underway in order to send the cases of these violators to environmental tribunal,” the official claimed, adding that presently industries falling in ‘A’ category were being focused by the Sepa teams.


He disclosed that although Sepa had also served notices to SITE Limited for the violations of environmental laws, its staff was cooperating and assisting Sepa teams in identifying the industries that were dumping their waste in open spaces and discharging effluent without treatment.


When asked whether it was the responsibility of an industrial unit to dispose of its waste at the landfill site of Gonpass or was it the job of industrial areas’ managements to do so, he said both the industries and the industrial areas’ managements were responsible for the safe disposal of industrial waste and effluent.


“Industrial areas’ managements charge some fees from industrial units for the disposal of solid waste by the industrial units and it is mainly their job to keep their controlled area clean of industrial waste. But individual industrial units are equally responsible as they would be held responsible in the court of law for violating the environmental laws,” the official added. Currently, Sepa was highly under-staffed and facing acute shortage of resources including vehicles and technical persons, the official maintained, adding that they had hired five vehicles to facilitate its staff for monitoring and inspection tasks.


“But I assure you that in the days to come, cases of many industrial units and authorities would be sent to environmental tribunal for causing environmental pollution and ignoring repeated warnings and notices by the Sepa,” he claimed.


On the other hand, industrial areas’ managements were also facing shortage of adequate funds and resources including the vehicles, machinery and personnel to keep their areas cleaned of industrial waste produced by the industries on daily basis, Sepa sources revealed. They said that although Sepa had decided to take up the issue of industrial pollution “very seriously” after its DG was reprimanded by Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry last month, the environmental watchdog was also emphasizing upon industrial areas’ managements to enhance their capacities and play their due role in preventing environmental pollution.


Sepa sources said that a comprehensive mechanism for industrial waste disposal, its monitoring as well as strict action against violators was required to tackle the issue of various kinds of industrial pollution, including solid waste dumping, effluent discharge or air pollution.


At the same time, Sepa needs a lot more resources like highly trained and skilled manpower and equipment including vehicles to perform its monitoring and prevention tasks effectively, they maintained.

 

(By M. Waqar Bhatti, The News-13, 06/04/2010)

 

 

 

 

Garbage dumping for land reclamation puts coastal communities’ livelihoods in jeopardy

 

Reclamation of coastal land by dumping truckloads of garbage around villages in Bin Qasim Town on a daily basis has created uncertainty among the residents who fear that they might lose their lands, graveyards, beautiful beaches and traditional jetties if the practice continued unchecked. Tons of garbage are brought from different towns of the city and dumped in coastal villages of Ibrahim Hydri, Rehri, Chashma Goth, Jatt Goth, Akbar Shah and Kalmati.


Local activists told The News that relevant officials, despite their repeated complaints, did nothing in regard to stopping this practice. Some of the activists recently threatened the owners of those vehicles that were dumping garbage in the area. “We told the owners we would burn their vehicles if the vehicles kept dumping urban waste in our villages,” they said. The activists said that dumping garbage at the beaches and grabbing of the reclaimed land had started many years ago. “Certain influential people sell the land to private firms for developing warehouses,” they added. Besides, they said, children of the area receive injuries while roaming on burning heaps of garbage to search for broken toys and valuable items.


The fisher folks living in the area consider the sea their mother. The beaches in the area, the activists said, were once famous for their scenic beauty but they now had been turned into garbage dumping sites. “We can’t let certain people to pollute our sea or use it for commercial purposes through practices such as reclamation of land,” they said, adding that they were already facing many problems, such as increasing marine pollution, depletion of mangroves forests and loss of fish stock in the sea near the coast. They also believed that if the sea was encroached from one side, it would start erosion from other sides. “Forget about launching a single project for our welfare, the waste of the entire city is being thrown at us,” they said.


Moreover, the sites where garbage trucks are being unloaded are the scenic points where the local people enjoy in evenings. The once-beautiful beaches have been covered by garbage and all one could see there is smoke. The activists linked the garbage dumping and land grabbing with the deprivation of the people of their amenity, saying that colonies would be established on the reclaimed land and people from outside would be settled there.


An activist, Karim Bux, said that trucks carried garbage and urban waste that were unloaded and then burnt them near their abodes. He said that they had sent applications to town and Union Council officials and the elected representatives in this regard but all in vain. “We can’t understand why they are reluctant to take any action” he said.


One fisherman, Allahdino, said that a mafia was involved in reclamation of land. He added that they now had to travel to Thatta and Balochistan waters in the search of fish as their beaches had become unproductive due to increasing marine pollution.


The coastal communities activists demanded the government to save their resources and mangroves forests and urged the concerned officials to take steps to stop seawater from being further polluted. Meanwhile, they warned the government and the elected representatives to stop reclamation of scenic beaches by dumping waste.

(By Jan Khaskheli, The News-19, 06/04/2010)

 

 

 

Toxic waste dumping at Gondal Pass threatening lives   


The lives and livelihood of tens of thousands of people is at stake because the powerful Sindh Industrial Trading Estate (SITE), in connivance with the Sindh Environmental Protection Agency (Sepa), is dumping toxic and industrial waste at Gondal Pass some 25km from the city without neutralising or segregating it, Dr Iqbal Saeed Khan, former acting director general, Sepa and an environmental scientist told The News. 


The dumping of industrial and toxic waste generated at SITE, Pakistan’s largest industrial estate, is being carried out after the Supreme Court of Pakistan took suo mutto note of the issue recently and ordered the SITE Association to dump its toxic and industrial material elsewhere so that tragedies such as the one that occurred in SITE a few years ago in which a child lost his life and another got auto amputated were not repeated.


“There should be sanitary landfills to dispose of toxic and industrial waste,” Dr Khan said. “The industrial and toxic waste should not be mixed with municipal waste and preferably it should be utilised at source and rendered non-reactive,” he said. However, toxic and industrial waste that contains about 2,000 different chemical compounds, including heavy metals, strong acids, strong alkalis and other agents which may lead to damage of biodiversity and water bodies was being dumped at Gondal Pass, Dr Khan said. He said that the minimum bare standards for dumping toxic and industrial waste should be a “triple layer of cemented floors and walls.” He pointed out that some three decades ago human beings, animals and plants at Love Canal in the United States suffered immensely although waste there was dumped in a deserted landfill site. 


The Sepa is supposed to monitor the dumping of toxic and industrial waste in accordance with the orders of the Supreme Court of Pakistan but it is merely a silent spectator. “The rationale behind the Supreme Court order is safe disposal of toxic and industrial waste,” Dr Khan said.


It may be recalled that the Supreme Court had directed the secretary Sepa and managing director SITE to conduct a “thorough enquiry” and submit elaborate reports in positive terms identifying the defects and shortfalls in protecting the environment security and safety under the law “within four weeks.”


The order was passed after a hearing in the Supreme Court on October 22 regarding the dumping of toxic waste in an industrial plot in Abidabad in SITE that devoured a child Iftikhar, 9, while another child Shiraz, 10, was seriously burnt and auto-imputed.

(By Shahid Husain, The News-13, 12/04/2010)